“It does not feel traditional and beachy…I have said it before, it is not evocative of what we were envisioning when we put together the bylaw for the NBOD,” said planning board member Jeanne Paquin. “George Washington Boulevard is every bit as important as the beach side because it is how people come into town…it is just a big, long wall along George Washington Boulevard.”
Planning board member Steve White said the plan is “dramatically better, but there is still a way to go…. when this is built, we all must feel this is a project we can be really proud of.”
Roache said feedback from the last hearing was the need to “understand the design context, how it fits in the neighborhood, and the need for more points of reference for the scale.”
Resident Kimberly Kingston said she “heard some fear of the project, but if not this, then what? … every time they [Procopio] have come they have been asked to do more and they have given more.”
“You come into town and Horizons is sitting there like a huge pumpkin. Add this edifice in front and it mutes it…more graceful entrance into town [and] won’t be as onerous,” said resident Bill Smyth.
In response to the boards and residents’ requests for a model of the development, Procopio created a 3D digital model fly-through to give a “real-time” sense of “scale, architecture, and flow.”
Procopio presented studies that predict $350K in net revenue to the town, $700K in building permit fees, slight increase in school-aged children, and an increase in activity in existing and new business from new residents.
Regarding flooding, Karlis Skulte, of Civil and Environmental Consultants, said there was a “significant improvement to the flood conveyance to accommodate pass-through flooding to the garage areas.”
Skulte said there are 185 parking spaces in the proposal, while only 177 are required under the zoning; the excess will be for visitors and other uses. Revisions to grading were also made to raise garage elevations and entries.
The stormwater management systems within the courtyards and parking area are designed to contain water from a 24-hour, 100-year storm event. “More refined stormwater evaluation” includes treating onsite stormwater prior to discharge, he said.
“We are going above and beyond the requirements,” said Skulte, saying that total water capture increased from 6,200 cubic feet to 9,000 cubic feet.
The developer’s consultant said the traffic impact study found “no significant impact,” said Erin Fredette of Bowman Consulting. Initially, the study was conducted in October and the boards requested analysis during peak traffic patterns.
Summer has 30% higher traffic, they added another 20% over the comparison for an increase of 50% in the sensitivity analysis. The study was conducted in 2019 at George Washington Boulevard, Rockland Circle, and the site driveway during weekday mornings and evenings. According to the study, the proposed development is “not estimated to have a significant impact on traffic operations within the study area.”
MJ Walsh of Rockland House Road said she finds it “hard to believe the traffic study concluded there is not a significant impact from an addition 132 residential units.”
The 1928 Paragon Carousel and its accompanying museum in the clocktower are next door to the project. Paquin said she has “great concerns of juxtaposition of the project to the carousel and the clocktower… [you] must respect what it is and surrounds.”
Paquin suggested a shadow study as well as a wind impact study be conducted.
Hibbard pointed out there is still a significant loss of commercial space.
Roache countered that “square footage is not everything; the quality of the space is more important…6% return on cost is minimum level.”
Smyth said the developers have “come a long way in modifying and revamping… it is good for the community; I think it is a go.”
Resident Pam Marlow agreed the design has “greatly improved from the beginning, but it still doesn’t seem like it works for Hull.”
The planning board review of the Paragon Dunes project was continued until Wednesday, February 28, with subsequent meetings already scheduled for March 6 and March 13.
Like what you’re reading? Stay informed with a Hull Times subscription by clicking here.
Do you have an opinion on this issue? Click here to write a Letter to the Editor.